Powered by WebAds

Saturday, August 26, 2006

Where will the 3rd Beis Hamikdash be built?

This sounds like a stupid question, the answer is obvious, in ירושלים on הר הבית.

However, the מלבי"ם and the רש"ש point out that the simple reading of the pesukim in יחזקאל פרק מ"ח is not that way.

The מלבי"ם in his commentary (יחזקאל מ"ג,ז) states that we see from the pesukim in פרק מ"ח that the Beis Hamikdash will be 25 mil from ירושלים on a different mountain. The רש"ש makes a similar comment (בבא בתרא קכ"ב). The Gemara there is discussing the חלוקת הארץ that will be when moshiach comes. The רש"ש points put out דרך אגב, that the simple reading of the pesukim in יחזקאל פרק מ"ח is that the Beis Hamikdash will be on a different mountain 25 mil from ירושלים and that this understanding can explain additional Pesukim in other places in נ"ך as well.

This opinion is clearly against the Rambam and I don't know of any earlier source who says like them.

The Rambam in (הלכות בית הבחירה (א,ג writes:
כיון שנבנה המקדש בירושלים--נאסרו כל המקומות כולן לבנות בהן בית לה', ולהקריב בהן קרבן; ואין שם בית לדורי הדורות אלא בירושלים בלבד, ובהר המורייה שבה--שנאמר "ויאמר דויד--זה הוא, בית ה' האלוהים; וזה מזבח לעולה, לישראל" (דברי הימים א כב,א), ואומר "זאת מנוחתי, עדי עד"

Once the Beis Hamikdash was built in Yerushalayim, it was prohibited to build a house for Hashem anywhere else and to bring sacrifices anywhere else. The only eternal house of Hashem is in Yerushalayim and on Har Hamoriah ...

Hopefully we will merit to see the resolution of this question very soon when Moshiach arrives.

3 Comments:

At 6:03 AM, Blogger pop said...

There is some medresh about the various mountains around yerishalim being flattened out lesod lavo. In that case it could be possible to redefine what constitues the same place.

For example if I take of fabric and fold it into a semi sphere on top of a surface. Then if I define some non central spot on the surface of the fabric as spot x. I then say it corresponds to spot y on the 2d surface below. Then I flatten the fabric on the 2d surface. Spot x on the facbric corresponds to a different spot on the 2d surface.

The same could apply to yerushalim. Thus one could use this to cler the following chakira. Is a mokom a din in the sorrespong surface on the sphere on the earth or is it a din on where it is even if is on some 3d surface above the earth that if flattened could end up corresponding to a different part of the earth.

 
At 5:46 PM, Blogger Eli said...

But not 25 mil away. That's like in Modiin or in Bet Shemesh.

 
At 3:57 AM, Blogger pop said...

It depends on the elevation of Jerusalem.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home