Thursday, February 02, 2012

R' Wein hits the nail right on the head


The most dreaded status in Israeli society is to be considered a frier - a sucker, a boob, stupid and unable to withstand being taken advantage of.  
The underlying motive for all of this Charedi bashing is that the Israeli public, including the divergent sections of it – religious, traditional, secular and Charedi light, is tired and disgusted at being a frier. It has had it with supporting a large and growing section of the Israeli population that it feels is being supported by the general public while itself contributing next to nothing to the general good and welfare of society.

It is useless to protest that the study and observance of Torah and the continuity of Eastern European or Sephardic traditions is somehow the guarantee of the continued existence of the State of Israel.

It is well recognized that thousands of Charedi young men are not really cut out to sit and study Talmud all day. The streets are full of them even if they are not yet those who have thrown off their garb and faith. Yet the rabbinic and Chasidic leaders of the Charedi community refuse to endorse the practical notion that these young men do national service stints - in hospitals, nursing homes, schools, shelters and other welfare institutions.

In this way they can fulfill their obligations to the state and society and allow themselves to obtain the necessary educational and vocational skills to enter the Israeli workforce and not be condemned to a lifetime of borrowing, charity and poverty. 

Is the sole and main purpose of the Charedi members of Knesset to allocate as much government funds as possible for the unemployed, the uneducated and the unappreciative at the expense of others in society?
And then there are the small things that have been raised to be great principles of faith in Charedi society that are continual irritations. I cannot understand why a prayer on behalf of the soldiers of the State of Israel is not allowed to be recited in Charedi synagogues and institutions of learning. Is this not the height of ingratitude when such prayers for the Czar’s army, the Turkish army and other “friendly” governments when we were in exile were recited?

It will be fascinating to see if someone like Yonasan Rosneblum responds to this.


Mighty Garnel Ironheart said...

No, RYR, RYA and RAS will all ignore this or will write some bland pap that acknowledges that there are "concerns" but not much more.
As for Rav Wein, I didn't know he'd become as much of a kofer as he has (kofer=person who thinks for himself)!

Neshama said...

I think Rabbi Wein has always "thought for himself" the same way that Rabbi Avigdor Miller zt'l earned his reputation of being an individual thinker.

Avi Greengart said...


You may want to reconsider whether the few bucks adsense throws your way is worth it. Perhaps Google is targeting me specifically (in which case it's even funnier/sadder), but here are the ads I just got on your site:

Rabbi Joel Goor
Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, Same-Sex & Interfaith Weddings a specialty.

Cantor Elissa Kaplan
Jewish, Interfaith, Same Sex Weddings. Glad to co-officiate